The Law and the Knowledge of Good and Evil: The Edenic Background of the Catalytic Operation of the Law in Paul
By Chris A. Vlachos, Ph.D. 2006
Wipf & Stock 2009
First Corinthians 15:56, "The sting of death is sin, and the
power of sin is the law," is both puzzling and neglected. It is
puzzling since there appears to be no precursor in 1 Corinthians to the
law-critical statement found there. It is neglected because of its
size. Nevertheless, the short verse offers the opportunity to analyze
in a rudimentary state Paul's law-sin notion that appears full-blown in
Romans, and the absence of a polemical setting allows scholars to
examine a law-critical statement issued during a polemical lull. In The
Law and Knowledge of Good and Evil, Vlachos weighs attempts to explain
the presence of 1 Cor 15:56 in 1 Corinthians and argues that the
Genesis Fall narrative, where the tempter plied his seductions by way
of the commandment, provides the theological substructure to Paul's
understanding of the law's provocation of sin. In doing so, Vlachos
contends that Paul reaches the historical high water mark of his
polemic against the salvific efficacy of the law by locating a law-sin
nexus in Eden, and, contrary to some recent perspectives on Paul, he
argues that the edenically informed axiom in 1 Cor 15:56 suggests that
Paul's fundamental concern with the law was rooted in primordial rather
than ethnic soil. While studies of Paul and the law have tended to
bypass Eden, The Law and Knowledge of Good and Evil breaks ground by
moving the argument beyond Second Temple Judaism to the Genesis Fall
account, where the prohibition against partaking of the knowledge of
good and evil led to the knowledge of sin.